APRA Joins in Friend of Court Brief to Oppose Post-Sale Restrictions of the Use and Repair of Patented Products - Engine Builder Magazine

APRA Joins in Friend of Court Brief to Oppose Post-Sale Restrictions of the Use and Repair of Patented Products

The Automotive Parts Remanufacturers Association (APRA) has joined with two other remanufacturing associations to file a friend of the court brief in the United States Supreme Court opposing efforts by a software company to use patent law to impose post-sale restrictions on the use of its patented products. If the right to impose such restrictions is upheld by the nation’s highest court, the manufacturer of a patented product could use restrictive language in its sales documents to not only prevent certain uses of the product, but also to limit or deny the purchaser the right to resell, repair, remanufacture or refurbish that product.

The legal issue is whether the rights of a patent holder terminate at the time of sale of the product or whether it can impose post-sale restrictions on the purchaser of that product. Since early in the 20th century US patent law has held that a patent holder’s rights are “exhausted” at the time of the first sale of the product and that after that the purchaser is free to use, resell or repair the item in any way it wishes. Citing that precedent the US District Court in Northern California found for the computer manufacturers and against LG. 

However, on appeal the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, which hears all patent law appeals, reversed saying that the exhaustion rule only applies to unconditional sales and that by imposing a condition on the sales of the chips, LG had retained its right to impose post-sale restrictions. In other words, any manufacturer may avoid the exhaustion doctrine simply by imposing whatever conditions it wanted at the time of the sale.

APRA joined in the battle on the side of Quanta and the other computer manufacturers to protect the long-standing right of consumers and businesses to repair products. This right to repair is the legal cornerstone on which the rebuilding and remanufacturing industry is based. If the motor vehicle companies are allowed to require that their products could not be repaired or that only authorized companies could repair or rebuild them, the independent vehicle parts remanufacturing industry would cease to exist.

The Engine Builders Association (AERA) and the International Imaging Technology Council, the trade association for toner cartridge rechargers, joined APRA on the brief. An additional brief supporting Quanta was filed on behalf of Dell, Hewlett-Packard, Cisco and EBay. The US Justice Department also filed a brief supporting Quanta.  Oral argument on the case was scheduled for January 16th.

You May Also Like

NMRA/NMCA Announce Augustine Herrera as National Tech Director

ProMedia Events and Publishing, the parent company of the Holley NMRA Ford Nationals and NMCA Muscle Car Nationals, has announced Augustine Herrera as the new NMRA/NMCA National Tech Director. His duties include overseeing fair competition in both drag racing series and leading the on-site tech staff at all national events.  “Augustine joined our team in

ProMedia Events and Publishing, the parent company of the Holley NMRA Ford Nationals and NMCA Muscle Car Nationals, has announced Augustine Herrera as the new NMRA/NMCA National Tech Director. His duties include overseeing fair competition in both drag racing series and leading the on-site tech staff at all national events. 

Shop Solutions November 2021

Check out these Shop Solutions from builders across the country!

Cam Center
Holley Classic Truck Battery Tray and Hold Down

Holley Classic Trucks can battery trays for 1981-1987 C/K Series trucks and Blazer/Jimmy/Suburban manufactured to precisely mimic the factory look with all of the original holes and contours. Related Articles – Rocker Arm Tech – Part 1 – Automotive Specialty-Equipment Retail Sales Reach New High – Rebuilders Choice Made from heavy-gauge steel and EDP coated

Holley Battery Tray
Rocker Arm Tech – Part 1

In this episode of Steve Tech, Steve Morris breaks down the fundamentals of rocker arms, rocker arm stands and valvetrain rocker arm geometry. Class is in session! Related Articles – The SCAT Story – Numbers Don’t Tell The Whole Story – Performance Rocker Arms

Automotive Specialty-Equipment Retail Sales Reach New High

Despite what occurred throughout 2020, the specialty-equipment industry showed resilience with industry retail sales climbing from $46.2 billion to a new high of $47.89 billion in the U.S., according to the new 2021 SEMA Market Report. Related Articles – Future of Engine Building: Converting the Masses – Future of Engine Building: The Road Ahead for

Other Posts

COMP Performance Group Announces Plans for 2013 Power Tour

The Power Tour is considered one of the biggest and best road trips in the nation for performance enthusiasts. A variety of special events are scheduled throughout the week, including a highly anticipated cruise night in downtown Memphis (home of CPG) on the Tuesday, June 4. Related Articles – New AETC Website Debuts – PRW

New AETC Website Debuts

Each year AETCbrings together engine builders, racers, engineers and media members from around the world to exchange information on the day’s most popular engine-building topics. In an effort to make information about the conference even more accessible, AETChas recently launched an updated, easy-to-navigate website. Related Articles – Eaton Sponsors Western Michigan University Student Race Car

PRW Opens New Corporate Office and Warehouse Distribution Center

The PRW warehouse distribution center and corporate headquarters in now located in Perris, California. In addition to being designed to maximize storage and order shipping, the facility has an abundance of office space that houses the sales, management and support teams, an employee break room, conference rooms, and a larger engineering and product development department.

Melling, Dura-Bond Consolidate Sales and Marketing Efforts

Charles Barnett, vice president of sales and marketing at Dura-Bond Bearing Co., will be heading up the consoliated efforts between Dura-Bond and Melling. Barnett has been a long-term employee at the company as president prior to the Melling purchase several years ago. He also had a career with ACDelco/General Motors and previously served as general sales