Regulations and Research: How PC-11 Became a CK-4/FA-4 Reality - Engine Builder Magazine

Regulations and Research: How PC-11 Became a CK-4/FA-4 Reality

PC-11 had its beginnings at least a decade ago due to the EPA and government regulators pushing for higher heavy-duty truck fuel economy standards. The American Engine Manufacturers Association (EMA) wrote a letter to the American Petroleum Institute (API) and the American Society for Testing of Materials (ASTM) asking for their help in developing new, more fuel efficient diesel engine oils. Everyone agreed that new heavy-duty engine oil specifications would be needed to improve fuel economy significantly. Engine manufacturers, chemical companies, and oil marketers then began the process of identifying new engine and lab tests to define the performance levels needed to create these oils. Considerable R & D has occurred since that letter.

PC-11 had its beginnings at least a decade ago due to the EPA and government regulators pushing for higher heavy-duty truck fuel economy standards. The American Engine Manufacturers Association (EMA) wrote a letter to the American Petroleum Institute (API) and the American Society for Testing of Materials (ASTM) asking for their help in developing new, more fuel efficient diesel engine oils. Everyone agreed that new heavy-duty engine oil specifications would be needed to improve fuel economy significantly. Engine manufacturers, chemical companies, and oil marketers then began the process of identifying new engine and lab tests to define the performance levels needed to create these oils. Considerable R & D has occurred since that letter.

Racers taught the industry long ago that lower viscosity oils could improve horsepower due to less friction and lower engine oil pumping requirements. It soon became obvious that vastly improved shear stability would be required if lower viscosity oils were to have adequate oil film strength to protect diesel engine components, which operated for much longer periods of time. Five years of lab testing and oil development resulted in the CK-4/FA-4 lube specs, which were introduced in December 2016.

First researchers realized that two oils were needed:

• A very low viscosity oil (API FA-4) for new engines designed to maximize fuel economy with tighter clearances.

• A somewhat higher viscosity oil for existing engine designs (API CK-4) to optimize fuel economy without damaging these engines.

To date, over 400 CK-4 and 60 FA-4 heavy-duty diesel engine oils have been approved for license.

The performance specifications for diesel and passenger car engine oils have been diverging for some time now.  API SN passenger car oils can contain no more than 0.08% wt. zinc dithiophosphate (ZDP) additives, and, if the oil is labelled “Resource Conserving”, it can contain no more than 0.06% wt. ZDP.  Remember, ZDP is the oil industry’s most effective extreme pressure (EP) agent and oxidation inhibitor.

Passenger car engines are expected to operate for 100,000 miles without problems.  Diesels, on the other hand, generally live for 4-10 times as long and work harder. I think ZDP levels should be between 0.08 and 1.0% wt. ZDP to adequately protect these engines, particularly as oil viscosity is reduced. If you’re running diesel engines, I would recommend that you purchase diesel only oils, not universal oils labeled API CK-4/SN to maximize ZDP content.  Never use oils labelled “for gasoline engines only.”

 

Several diesel engine manufacturers are not completely satisfied with these new specifications. But, we must remember that this dissatisfaction could be a commercial maneuver, rather than a technical matter. I still vividly remember a commercial decision made by an engine OEM vice president and an oil marketer vice president at a Surfer’s Paradise Indy car race in Australia several years ago. These geniuses agreed to jointly market a “premium” diesel engine oil under both companies’ brand names without any technical input.

When the technical people got together to “make it happen”, they quickly realized that neither the engine OEM and the oil marketer had no idea how to make such a premium oil. The oil marketer wasn’t even known as a strong diesel “player” in the marketplace. A joint meeting with Lubrizol’s chemists was quickly scheduled. They decided what this oil should do, and Lubrizol decided what the chemical formulation should look like. A very successful joint product was the result.

Since the CK-4/FA-4 specs were finalized, we’ve heard several OEMs voice their opinions about the new oils. A summary of their current positions appears below.

Cummins approves both CK-4 and FA-4 oils, which meet its CES 20086 and CES 20087 specifications, but Cummins doesn’t endorse all CK-4 and FA-4 oils. Cummins’ Oilguard program also allows extended oil change intervals with these oils if oil analysis is conducted using Cummins analytical suppliers. Cummins also allows a 10,000 mile drain interval extension when using Cummins/Valvoline Premium Blue 8600 in its X15 engines.

Detroit Diesel has issued a DFS 93K222 specification, which CK-4 oils must meet and a DFS 9K223 specification for API FA-4 oils to meet. They are using an FA-4 oil for factory fill on its DD13, DD15, and DD16 engines.  They are also introducing an Efficient Long Haul specification for extended oil change intervals.

Ford is recommending the use of its new Motorcraft diesel engine oil for its Super Duty trucks. They are warning commercial customers to avoid using most new CK-4/FA-4 oils due to concerns about high-mileage wear rates.

Ford is telling fleets not to use CK-4/SN oils unless they have proven to meet the Ford WSS-M2C171-F1 specifications. Apparently this specification will approve only SAE XW-40 grade oils, not XW-30 grade oils. This suggests to me that Ford’s 6.7L diesel may be having some high-temperature wear problems. Fiat Chrysler encountered a similar problem with its Eco Diesel engine last year. They eventually banned the use of 5W-30 European diesel oils and required the use of 10W-X or 5W-40 and thicker oils in its service bulletin. The European oil spec calls for low levels of ZDP.

International is promoting a 70,000 mile oil drain interval with its A26 MAN-based engine family. This is no surprise, because Europeans have recommended longer oil change intervals for years. To date, they haven’t taken a position on the new oils.

Kenworth recently announced a 60,000 mile oil change interval for its fleet vehicles. This is accomplished by utilizing a larger oil sump combined with a centrifugal oil filter. The added volume is sufficient to extend drain intervals. Again, they have not mentioned the new oils.

Mack has also introduced the concept of extended oil change intervals only when using its proprietary Mack EOS-4.5 engine oil. Mack claims the new EOS-4.5 oil is a proprietary formulation, which is better than CK-4 spec oils. This oil is backwards compatible with all engines using API CJ-4 and CK-4 oils.

Volvo has been silent thus far, but I expect it will use the same approach as Mack since the two are essentially the same company.

In Europe, two factors support OEM branded diesel oils. First, there are few aftermarket maintenance shops, so truckers are forced to use dealerships to perform maintenance. Second, there are few large fleets in Europe, so diesel OEMs can use the warranty lever (even though it’s not legal in the U. S.) to encourage the use of their more expensive proprietary oils.

The situation is different in this country.  As one large fleet executive once told me, “I do what I please.” Their purchasing power overrules all warranty considerations. However, if you are building for a smaller operation, it might be smarter just to recommend they “go with the flow” until the warranty period is over. Size does matter!

You May Also Like

LTR Engine Build

This Late Model Engines build is centered around Concept Performance’s new LTR block, which is the first aftermarket as-cast aluminum Gen V LT block. 

The Chevrolet LT engine family from General Motors is rooted in the early ‘70s, when the LT1 was featured in the Corvette and Camaro Z28. After a 20-year hiatus, GM reintroduced the platform in the early ‘90s. The “LT1 350” came out in 1991, and was distinct from the high-output Gen I LT1 of the 1970s. It displaced 5.7L (350 cu in), and was a two-valve per cylinder pushrod design. The LT1 used a reverse-flow cooling system, which cooled the cylinder heads first, maintaining lower combustion chamber temperatures and allowing the engine to run at a higher compression than its immediate predecessors.

LS Intake Manifolds

LS swaps are popular for many reasons, but there are a lot of variations and details to sort through – more of them than you may expect – and many of them are associated with the intake manifold.

LS Cylinder Heads

The LS engine is known for its cylinder heads, and there are tons of options available to upgrade the factory components.

Choosing the Correct Block for Your LS Engine Build

Whether you’re scouring junkyards, ordering cores, investigating factory options, looking at aftermarket cast iron or aluminum blocks, or spending big bucks on billet LS blocks, you’ve probably noticed it’s been harder to find exactly what you want for the foundation of your LS build than it historically has.

Open Loop/Closed Loop and Learning

Closed-loop control can be programmed to either add or subtract up to a certain percentage of fuel in order for the engine to reach the target air/fuel ratio.

Other Posts

How Ambient Temperatures Affect Diesel Oil Choice

When it comes to oil choices, you can opt to go after viscosities that provide better fuel economy or those that give your engine better protection. You can’t have both. Either way you choose, you’ll also want to consider the ambient temperatures in your area for best results. We get into the details of oil

Liqui Moly Sponsors Formula 1 for Fifth Year

The German oil manufacturer, LIQUI MOLY, announced it will return to the “pinnacle of motorsport” with renewal for 2023 season of Formula 1 after signing a 1-year contract with the racing series. This will be the company’s fifth consecutive year sponsoring Formula 1. Related Articles – Tick Performance is Under New Ownership – Drag-and-Drive World

Hot Shot’s Secret Releases New Product Guide

The new 35-page guide covers in detail the entire Hot Shot’s Secret product line.

Shop Solutions January 2023

Next time you have set of large journal small block Chevy connecting rods to resize, consider honing the big ends of them for a +.002” outside diameter bearing that the LS engines with fracture cap rods use.