Advertising Does Not Work, And I Can Prove It! - Engine Builder Magazine

Advertising Does Not Work, And I Can Prove It!

There was a time when I only relied on word of mouth, the yellow pages and
an occasional ad in the local paper. I would throw together an ad myself and
when the results were poor, I would convince myself it was because advertising
did not work –when this simply was not true. In today’s world of business, if
you don’t have effective advertising and marketing programs, you are going to
find it nearly impossible to compete in the future.

The fact is, as business owners we need to be constantly thinking of ways to
grow our companies, and advertising and marketing must be part of our business
plans. The problem is that we are often unsure about the effectiveness of our
advertising and feel that a lot of our advertising dollars are wasted. John
Wanamaker, considered the father of both the modern department store and modern
advertising, was quoted as saying: “I know that half of my advertising dollars
are wasted … I just don’t know which half.” Although there is some truth to
this, it should not deter you away from advertising and marketing. There are
things you can do to minimize the losses and increase the gains with an
effective advertising plan. The rewards of an effective plan far outweigh the
losses incurred when one of your ads or a promotion is not working.

Four years ago, when I was planning to build a new facility and expand my
shop, I knew that in order to succeed I needed to gain market share in my area
quickly, and could not rely on word of mouth alone. In order to grow at a
faster pace, I needed to put together a comprehensive advertising/marketing
program. With the help from a business consultant we set out to determine a few
critical factors; who my profile customer is, what products and services I want
to bring to the consumer, and where to find more of my profile customer. I want
to share with you some of what I learned from my experience, and what forms of
advertising are working for us.

– There are some who say advertising does not work; that’s a myth. The right
advertising works and you need to find out what works for you. You need to
conduct a demographics study of your current customer base and the consumer
base in your potential market area. Establish what your business is all about,
and what you bring to the market that sets you apart from your competition.
Create a profile from your existing customer base to determine your ideal
customer. Create an advertising program to attract more customers who fit your
ideal profile. Find out where these people are in your market area and target
these people. Your advertising does not
belong in a discount publication. Remember; don’t try to be everything to

– Don’t be afraid to try different forms of advertising; fear, sometimes
keeps us from achieving our potential. If something does not work, stop doing
it. Try something else. That’s not failure; you have just gained knowledge that
you did not have before. Don’t try everything at once either, build upon your
program. Also, you need a blend of call-to-action and branding. You don’t
always need to offer a coupon or discount. With our radio ads, we give seasonal
auto tips during peak drive times. Sometimes it’s better to brand your company
by getting your name out, than offering a discounted service.

– Is word of mouth the best form of advertising? Yes and no. Word of mouth
is great, but it can be too slow. Several years back, I considered word of
mouth to be my best form of advertising, while the truth was; I really did not
have a well thought-out plan.

– Many people say you can’t measure advertising. I don’t totally agree with
that statement either. Every customer, new and existing, needs to be asked how
they found you. You need to track and monitor this. I keep a spreadsheet of
every contact I make; I want to know exactly how someone found us. This way I
will know what works and what does not work.

– All your advertising must be consistent in the message, colors, and logos.
When someone sees your company, whether it’s on your website, TV, promotional
flyer or print ad, it must be easily recognizable. Branding is everything. Don’t
send mixed messages. That does not mean you can’t have different themes. Geico
Insurance uses multiples themes. We all know the gecko and caveman commercials
and easily associate these ads with Geico. I recommend recruiting the help from
a professional marketing company to help you create an effective program.

– The key to remember about advertising is that once you create a program
along with a budget, you need to commit to that plan for the long haul. Your
advertising must be consistent and continual. Inconsistent advertising does not
work and actually ends up wasting valuable dollars.

– People will buy your product or service when they are ready to buy, not
necessarily when you are ready to sell. Just because a direct marketing
promotion did not yield the results you were looking for, does not mean it
failed. Keeping your company in the mind of the consumer through consistent
advertising is powerful, and will ultimately have positive results. Think of it
this way; Dunkin Donuts does not expect you to jump off your couch every time
it airs a TV commercial, does it? No. The purpose of the commercial is to keep
embedding the Dunkin Donuts brand into your mind, which in turn increases their
odds that you will choose Dunkin Donuts the next time you are traveling down
the road looking for coffee and donuts.

After two years since starting our new marketing program, we now concentrate
on TV, Radio, Internet marketing, email marketing and social media. This is
what is working for us now. It may change in the future. That’s business. You
need to do your homework and find out what will work for you. You will need to
continually monitor and measure the effectiveness and make changes as you see
fit, it’s an on-going process.

Let me leave you with these thoughts; if you are not willing to advertise to
your customer, I promise you, someone else will. Don’t get discouraged either;
it takes time to establish your company in the market place. It’s like planting
seeds; it takes time to see something growing from the earth.

So, let me rephrase the title of this article: Advertising Does Not
Work, the Right Advertising Works!

article was contributed by Joe Marconi of Elite. Joe is one of the 1-on-1
business coaches who helps shop owners build more successful businesses through
Elite Coaching
and is the co-founder of

You May Also Like

HP Academy Teaches EFI Online

The HP Academy was started to fulfill the need for some sort of formal training for EFI tuning. Two New Zealanders, Andre Simon and Ben Silcock, founded HPA in 2010.

With the ongoing COVID-19 situation, classrooms, as we know them, are not in session. You can’t physically distance in a small class in real life, but you can online. Virtual learning is now the new norm across the country. The racing industry is getting a leg up thanks to one school that is dedicated to online education. 

Utilizing Instagram

“When we started, we had no business at all… that’s when I started using Instagram,” Yaghoubian says. “Back then I didn’t know a lot about social media, but it works for business really well, and especially the automotive industry on Instagram.”

Higher Revving Education

We’ve all seen the ads in magazines and online for schools, classes and seminars on tuning an ever-increasing number of engines and even transmissions in today’s cars and trucks. The better ones will include the use of a chassis dyno to show real-time results of the step-by-step methods they teach.

Chassis vs Engine Dyno

We spoke with a couple shops that utilize both dyno types to get their take on the advantages, disadvantages and reasons to have one over the other or both.

Tradeshow Season

While the rest of the world tends to slow down in the fourth quarter, our industry is starting to rev up. That’s because it’s tradeshow season, and the excitement for next year is always palpable!

Other Posts

OE Parts vs. the Aftermarket

Many of your customers believe that OEM parts are better than aftermarket parts. We wanted to dispel some of the myths once and for all. Without getting into the mud about which brands are better. It is important to note that not all parts are created equal, and this includes both aftermarket and OE replacement parts.

Setting Up an Instagram Account

The old saying goes, “A picture is worth 1,000 words.” Well, in the world of social media, that same picture is not just worth 1,000 words, but could also be worth thousands of dollars in new business for your engine shop. By now you’ve likely seen our features on setting up and utilizing Facebook for your business. Next on our ‘to-do list’ is an introduction to Instagram for those of you who haven’t started utilizing this social media platform.

The Potential in Differential

Is growth part of your business strategy? It comes in a lot of different forms, but when it’s adding a new service offering or product for your customers, it can be nerve-racking at the very least. The additional investment in tools, equipment, training or people weighed against the unknown outcome leaves you holding all the risk, unless there is something that’s a perfect fit.

How To Put Your Facebook Page To Work

A couple months ago, we walked you through the setup of a Facebook business page. Hopefully you’ve gone ahead and created that page and took some time over the last couple months to play around with ways to engage with an audience. If not, go back and check out the February issue. It’s worth your while to do so!